This year, half a million students
competed for 9,647 spots at the Indian Institutes of Technology. Kota
has emerged as a “cram capital” for the exams.
The fourth of seven children of illiterate
parents, Mohammad Ahmad grew up on his family's two-acre farm with
barely enough to eat. Now that farm, which supports two dozen people in
his extended family, is being used as collateral for a chance to score
big here in India's cram school capital.
For
up to 19 hours a day, seven days a week, the 17-year-old studies,
attends classes and takes mock tests, preparing for India's
ultra-competitive engineering entrance exam.
In this second-tier
city of dusty storefronts and belching rickshaws, Ahmad and the tens of
thousands of other students embody a nation's hunger for upward
mobility, social respect and a role in the new India. One can almost
hear the angst in the creak of cheap student bicycles and the mantra of
parents: Forget exercise, dating, video games. How will you ever get
into engineering school if you don't study more?
The Holy Grail is
a spot at one of 15 Indian Institutes of Technology, or IITs. Admission
is blisteringly difficult -- think Harvard, Princeton and MIT combined.
This year, half a million test takers nationwide elbowed for 9,647
spots. As CBS' "60 Minutes" said, the IITs are "the most important
university you've never heard of."
Driving India's love affair
with the schools is the promise of higher income, social status, even
marriage prospects. Graduates command high salaries, better dowry terms
and promising job offers with top Indian and multinational companies.
Although many don't ultimately go into engineering, an IIT degree can
open doors.
But the entrance exam's 98% failure rate can destroy
the dreams of families such as Ahmad's that can ill afford the fees,
which approach $1,400 annually.
"This isn't competition, it's
gambling," said Abdul Mabood, director of the national help line Snehi,
which counsels stressed students, including the legions who travel to
this northern city where billboards aplenty promise success: "Unbeatable
Performance!" says one. "Bull's Eye Classes," reads another.
Kota's emergence as cram capital for the 4 1/2-hour annual IIT entrance exam owes much to serendipity.
In
the mid-1980s, mechanical engineer V.K. Bansal received a diagnosis of
muscular dystrophy, quit his job and started coaching IIT aspirants in
his kitchen. A few years later, fellow IIT graduate Pramod Maheshwari
abandoned dreams of living in the U.S. after protests from his mother
and started coaching from his garage.
Both saw their students do
well -- IIT admissions are so celebrated that top entrants are
front-page news -- and word spread. In 2000, a Bansal student garnered
the highest score in India. "It was a gold medal for us," said A.K.
Tiwari, Bansal's chief technology officer in a company that now has
17,000 students and dozens of teachers and administrators.
Both
Bansal and Maheshwari are now multimillionaires running massive
competing schools. In fact, once-industrial Kota boasts 129 "coaching
institutes," from holes in the wall to marble-gilded learning factories.
"I
haven't seen a single parent say they don't have the money -- they'll
sell land, borrow, anything," said Prakash Joy, president of Ables
Educations, another Kota cram school.
Spots at the top cram
schools are so coveted that entrants take tests to join, even as schools
compete to retain top instructors for programs ranging from four months
to two years. "Poaching comes with coaching," said Maheshwari, whose
Career Point institute boasts 20,000 of Kota's estimated 100,000
students.
For anxious parents, a key attraction to Kota is its
near-complete lack of multiplex theaters or pubs. "I have no friends
here," said Surabhi Kumari, 17, at Career Point. "My father doesn't want
me using my phone. I'm here to study."
Local families in
conservative Kota, traditionally known for its woven saris and Mughal
military legacy, also play their part. While renting out rooms to
students, many serve as surrogate parents, keeping careful watch over
their young tenants, tracking their whereabouts and discouraging
horseplay.
Four years ago, the city opened its first mall, but
most students are so focused they don't know where it is, said Sumit
Chaturvedi, 32, who runs hostels for boys and girls. (Separate, of
course.) Recently, Chaturvedi evicted a boy for smoking so he wouldn't
influence others.
"We keep these things in mind," he said. "Kota
is much better for studying. Most big cities have lots of entertainment
and distractions."
The IITs are the pride of India, largely free
of politics or corruption, earning kudos in 2003 from Microsoft's Bill
Gates for helping build Silicon Valley. Indeed, the cram schools and
IITs have been criticized for subsidizing brain drain. An old joke holds
that IIT graduates have one foot in India, the other aboard Air India.
Others question whether success comes at the cost of creative thinking.
"This
has become an exercise much more in memorization rather than helping
independent thinking," said N.R. Narayana Murthy, founder of high-tech
pioneer Infosys, who says 80% of IIT graduates leave much to be desired.
The
grueling process carries another price. "People who miss passing by
one-tenth of a percent think they're failures," said Shiv Visvanathan, a
sociology professor at O.P. Jindal Global University in Sonipat. "It's
mass production of engineers, many of whom don't want to be engineers.
The dream has become a nightmare."
Some of the ambivalence was
captured in the 2009 Bollywood blockbuster "Three Idiots," about three
engineering students, only one of whom enjoys engineering. "I will curse
you the rest of my life if you force me" to become an engineer, one
character tells his father. "Please, let me do what I want."
Coaching
institutes deny they foster an over-reliance on rote and argue that the
IITs are a means to an end. Only 20% to 25% "of people end up in
engineering," said Career Point founder Maheshwari. "But you essentially
go through a process and become logical and creative."
Tiwari,
Bansal's technology head, pops into classrooms on an overcast afternoon
where as many as 140 students at narrow desks watch teachers solve
problems on overhead projectors. "If the government schools were doing
their jobs, there'd be no need for coaching," he said.
Although
Ahmad's family is very poor, his brother Nizamuddin, 28, a doctor's
assistant, wanted him to dream big. When other family members balked at
Kota's steep fees, the brother lobbied relentlessly, helping secure a
$1,100 loan backed by the farm.
"He's been like a father to me, hellbent on finding a way for me to study," Ahmad said. "I owe him everything."
Even
so, Ahmad arrived in Kota $950 short for the two-year cram course.
Administrators denigrated him for being poor, Ahmad said, urging him to
quit and barring him from classes. But his brother eventually scrounged
together most of the shortfall.
Ahmad says his studying is coming
along, although living in Kota is expensive. "The rich students spend
money like water," he said. "Some laugh at me for being poor, but I
ignore them."
Rising at 5 a.m., he studies chemistry and physics
until noon, takes classes all afternoon, then studies until midnight,
knowing how much depends on his results. He dreams of getting a good
job, buying a laptop and supporting his parents.
"For engineers,
the sky is the limit," he said. "It's a risk, but I'd never forgive
myself for staying in the village and never trying."
mark.magnier@latimes.com